Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Suman Suhag's avatar

It is not about having nothing to hide, it is about having something that is yours. The moment government ask for access to our digital lives, they produce the same mantra: "If you have nothing to hide, then there is nothing to worry about". This totally misses the point.

The question you have to ask yourself is not have you done nothing wrong.

Do you trust that today’s, tomorrow’s, and future government/governments will have complete and unchecked access to your personal information just because the technology to do it exist. History has proven governments change, the laws change, and priorities change, actions that are legal today may be outlawed or monitored or punishable tomorrow. We may relinquish the right we have today that we may regret tomorrow. Edward Snowden is often quoted: “Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.”

Locking your door, changing your passwords, drawing your curtains and talking privately is not because you are trying to conceal your criminal activity, but because it is part of being a free citizen.

Government does play a role in security and ensuring people safety, however that must be proportionate to the liberty enjoyed by the citizenry, not an intrusion just because technology allow for it. Australians need to ask themselves what limits on government power do we want to impose now because if one government has the power, so will the next. The Constitution begins with: “Whereas the people”.

A statement reminding people that governments exist to serve people and not vice-versa. Liberty is not lost in an instance, but incrementally in the name of some cause or the next. The defense of privacy is not a defense of technology but it is a defense of liberty which makes for a democracy worth defending.

William's avatar

They had ample warning. Ba’al save the queen

No posts

Ready for more?